Good-hearted human adopts 5-week-old Doberman Pincher without realizing he's too young to foster, she seeks internet advice on best next steps for the puppy's health

Fostering a 5-week-old Doberman Pinscher can sound sweet and heroic, but in reality it's not an ideal situation for the puppy's development or for the foster home.

If only the woman in the story knew that to begin with. She has a heart of gold, wanting to care for and foster an adorable Doberman Pincher puppy, but things go astray when she realizes that the puppy is actually too young to be in foster care without its mom. She asks the internet for advice, and even calls a vet, but is only left without options. The vet tells her the puppy will be okay, but in the end will he? Let's learn about some reasons why 5-weeks-old is too young. First of all, it's too young to be separated from the mother and brothers and sisters. Puppies learn crucial skills between 5 and 8 weeks old. It's when they discover bite techniques and master pressure. They learn body language cues, tolerance of frustrations, and pack dynamics. They can grow up with poor social boundaries if they're removed too early, just like a person wouldn't probably develop if they were separated from a good home too young too. Read the full story below to fully understand what happens, and to see what the internet has to say.

01

via u/Dre2xi
02

via u/Dre2xi
03

via u/Dre2xi
04

via u/Dre2xi
05

via u/Dre2xi
06

via u/Dre2xi
Dobermans are a high-drive, intelligent working breed. Even as babies, they require structure and appropriate stimulation. A five-week-old puppy isn’t ready for formal training yet, but they do require near-constant supervision. At that age, they’re still developing bladder control, chewing boundaries, and sleep rhythms. A foster would need to be available almost full-time — including overnight — because puppies that young can’t self-regulate well.
07

via u/Dre2xi
08

via u/coldtrance
09

via u/coldtrance
10

via u/coldtrance
If the puppy is taken away from its mother too early, it can develop negative skills such as biting too hard, struggling with other dogs, or developing anxiety. Those early weeks aren't just cuddly time; they're foundational behavioral training provided naturally by the mother and siblings.
11

via u/coldtrance
12

via u/coldtrance
13

via u/coldtrance
14

via u/coldtrance
Another concern is attachment and transition stress. Puppies separated early may bond intensely and quickly. If the foster placement is temporary (as fostering usually is), that early emotional attachment followed by rehoming can contribute to insecurity later. While many dogs adjust fine, early instability during a critical developmental window isn’t ideal.
15

via u/cefli
16

via u/cefli
17

via u/cefli
18

via u/Kermit1420
19

via u/Kermit1420
20

via u/Kermit1420